The Collector’s Souvenirs: the Rothschild Medal Cabinets

Fifteen years separated Calouste Gulbenkian's initial observation of two works from the Rothschild collection and their eventual purchase. This article by curator Vera Mariz examines the story behind these acquisitions.
Vera Mariz 07 May 2025 5 min
The Travels of Calouste Gulbenkian

Calouste Gulbenkian’s immersion in Vienna’s art collections during his study trip to the Austrian capital in 1933 sparked in the collector a desire to make new acquisitions for his collection. By this time an experienced collector, his already lofty standards had risen further, leading him to make fewer acquisitions. For this reason, the interest he showed in this case was of great significance. Essentially, the Collector’s exceptional purchases from the Hermitage Museum had made him reluctant to make acquisitions that did not add significant value to his collection. As such, at that time, he was focused only on objects of ‘transcendental’ quality.

At the Museum für Kunst und Industrie, where he spent several hours on different days, Gulbenkian amused himself by pondering how many carpets from the exceptional collection he would take home with him if given the chance. After careful observation, he eventually decided that ‘There are 16 carpets that would delight the most demanding of collectors.’ Among them would certainly be one specimen that he described at the time as the most beautiful piece of Persian textile art in the world, a Safavid silk carpet depicting hunting scenes, which is still one of the foremost works in what today is known as the MAK – Museum für angewandte Kunst.

Albert Rothschild Palace, 24-26 Heugasse, Vienna. Paul Kortz, ‘Wien am Anfang des XX. Jahrhunderts’. Vienna, 1905, vol. II.
Albert Rothschild Palace, 24-26 Heugasse, Vienna.

Thanks to his contacts in the city, namely the A. S. Drey and Pollak & Winternitz art galleries, as well as the art historian Leo Planiscig, Gulbenkian was also able to visit some of Vienna’s leading private collections during his trip, in particular the Rothschild, Liechtenstein, Clam-Gallas, Harrach, Czernin, Figdor and Benda collections. However, with a few exceptions, he felt these collections to be somewhat overrated. Nevertheless, during his visit to the Liechtenstein Palace, he came across a ‘Polonaise’ carpet in the imposing entrance hall that truly captivated him, not only for the beautiful design and rich colours, but also for its excellent condition. A great admirer and collector of these types of Persian carpets, he considered the piece an ‘excellent acquisition, if feasible.’

Alphonse Rothschild Palace, Theresianumgasse 16-18, Vienna. Paul Kortz, ‘Wien am Anfang des XX. Jahrhunderts’. Vienna, 1905, vol. II.
Alphonse Rothschild Palace, Theresianumgasse 16-18, Vienna.

At Theresianumgasse 16-18, the Collector visited one of the city’s five Rothschild palaces. Originally built by Nathaniel von Rothschild, the Neo-Baroque building and its magnificent art collections were inherited by his nephew, Alphonse Mayer von Rothschild, also a collector. Despite the remarkable international reputation of the collections amassed there, Gulbenkian was underwhelmed by the ensemble: ‘With the exception of six or seven pieces, I was disappointed.’

Jean-Honoré Fragonard, ‘The See-Saw’. France, ca. 1750-1752. Oil on canvas. Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, Inv. no. 148 (1956.13) © Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza. Madrid.
Jean-Honoré Fragonard, ‘The See-Saw’. © Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza. Madrid.

Sharing the Rothschild barons’ predilection for eighteenth-century French art, it is unsurprising that the Collector highlighted pieces of furniture from the reigns of Louis XV and Louis XVI in particular. Also in keeping with his penchant for painting, he remarked on the presence of a Guardi fire scene – a theme absent from his collection of works by the Venetian artist – and a pair of paintings by Fragonard depicting scenes of young love: The Swing and Blind Man’s Bluff, which he did not find to be particularly extraordinary. Of the works he considered most interesting, two impressive Regency-style medal cabinets, described as being of ‘very good quality,’ were the only firm additions to his list of desirable acquisitions.

Jean-Honoré Fragonard, ‘Blind-Man’s Buff’. France, ca. 1750-1752. Oil on canvas. Toledo Museum of Art, Purchased with funds from the Libbey Endowment, Gift of Edward Drummond Libbey, inv. 1954.43. © Toledo Museum of Art, Toledo, Ohio.
Jean-Honoré Fragonard, ‘Blind-Man’s Buff’. © Toledo Museum of Art, Toledo, Ohio.

After returning to Paris, Gulbenkian maintained regular contact with Siegfried Drey, the art dealer who had accompanied him on his visit to the Rothschild palace and who was charged with negotiating a possible sale of the furniture and other objects. However, after months of negotiations, in January 1934, Drey finally concluded that Alphonse von Rothschild was unwilling to sell any works from his collection for the time being. The said collection would subsequently be confiscated by the Gestapo in March 1938, following the annexation of Austria by Germany and the implementation of the Nuremberg Laws. The palace suffered a similar fate, being heavily damaged by air raids during the war and subsequently demolished.

The collection was not returned to Clarice Rothschild, Alphonse von Rothschild’s wife, until 1947, when negotiations were brokered to export the objects to the United States, where the widow lived, a controversial donation of 250 works to the Austrian government being agreed as a condition. Among the works to make their way across the Atlantic following their recovery from the Altaussee salt mines and other deposits of art looted by the Nazis, was the pair of medal cabinets that Calouste Gulbenkian had attempted to acquire 15 years earlier.
Charles Cressent, Pair of Medal Cabinets (detail). France, c. 1750. Structure in oak veneered with satinwood, amaranth, boxwood, and ebony; chased and gilded bronze. Calouste Gulbenkian Museum, inv. 2368A/B.
Charles Cressent, Pair of Medal Cabinets (detail). France, c. 1750. Structure in oak veneered with satinwood, amaranth, boxwood, and ebony; chased and gilded bronze. © Calouste Gulbenkian Museum.

The Collector made another offer in February 1948, via Hans Stiebel, to whom he had recently reiterated his interest in works of ‘transcendental, outstanding quality.’ This was undoubtedly the case with the medal cabinets by Charles Cressent, the most famous of the Regency-style cabinet-makers. After negotiating the initial price and confirming that there were no restorations, that the bronze was originally gilded and that the two pieces of furniture were in perfect condition, the transaction was finalised in under two months.

View of the room at the National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C., with the medal cabinets from the Gulbenkian collection. Courtesy of the Archives of the National Gallery of Art.
View of the room at the National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C., with the medal cabinets from the Gulbenkian collection. © National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C.

Calouste Gulbenkian would never again personally see the medal cabinets he had so admired on his trip to Vienna. Having lived in Lisbon since 1942, he arranged with John Walker, chief curator at the National Gallery of Art, for the two pieces to be sent immediately to Washington D.C., where part of his collection was already on loan. The exceptional pair of medal cabinets was not transferred to Lisbon until 1960, along with the other future Calouste Gulbenkian Museum works, where it remains to this day as one of the most eloquent testimonies to the Collector’s persistence.

Series

The Travels of Calouste Gulbenkian

From visits to museums, monuments, and historical sites, from Europe to the Near East, to consolidate his artistic education; to invigorating stays at the most sophisticated European seaside resorts and thermal spas, this series follows Calouste Gulbenkian on the most memorable travels of his life.
Know more

You may also like

Cookies settings

Cookies Selection

This website uses cookies to improve your browsing experience, security, and its website performance. We may also use cookies to share information on social media and to display messages and advertisements personalised to your interests, both on our website and in others.